Andrew F. Dukes built this house around 1873. The 1892 commercial directory for East New Market, lists Andrew F. Dukes as a carpenter. A tax assessment record for 1873 lists this property as a 'new house'.
In 1990, James Cheesman (b. 1895) stated "And then, the next place is where the Flowers woman was. Of course it has been rebuilt too. A fellow named John Smith lived in that. It was not quite as big as it is now."